Most Long Island homeowners with a standard 275-gallon tank order somewhere between 100 and 250 gallons at a time, depending on how much is left in the tank. The right amount is whatever fills the tank without overfilling it, and a fill typically stops short of the tank’s full capacity. Check your gauge first, then order enough to get comfortably through the next stretch of cold weather.
Start with your tank size
A typical residential indoor heating oil tank holds about 275 gallons. Some homes have two tanks, a larger tank, or an outdoor or buried tank. Look for a label on the tank or ask your heating service technician what you have.
A tank is never filled to the last drop. Oil needs room at the top to expand, and the fill pipe and vent need clear space, so the practical fill is lower than the number on the label. That is why ordering the full tank size does not work, and why it helps to know what is already in the tank.
Read the gauge before you order
Most tanks have a float gauge on top. It usually reads in fractions: empty, one-quarter, one-half, three-quarters, full. Here is a rough guide for a 275-gallon tank. Gauges are approximate, and tank shapes vary, so treat these as ballpark figures.
| Gauge reads | Oil left, roughly | Room to add, roughly |
|---|---|---|
| One-quarter | about 70 gallons | about 200 gallons |
| One-half | about 140 gallons | about 135 gallons |
| Three-quarters | about 205 gallons | about 70 gallons |
If the gauge is stuck or you do not trust it, ask your technician for another way to measure. Our guide to safely checking your heating oil tank level covers the common methods.
How much oil will your house use?
There is no single number. Use depends on the size of the house, insulation, windows, how old the equipment is, the thermostat setting, and how cold the winter turns out. Two similar houses on the same street can burn quite different amounts.
The best guide is your own history. Look at past delivery receipts or your account’s order history, and note how many gallons you took each time and how many weeks apart the fills were. If you ordered 200 gallons and it lasted about six weeks in January, that tells you more than any rule of thumb. Keep a simple note of the date, gauge reading and gallons for each fill.
Small orders or a full fill?
You have a few sensible choices.
- Smaller, more frequent orders. A 100 or 150 gallon order can work if cash is tight or you only need to get through a few weeks. Online, you can pick from 50, 100, 150, 200, 250, 300 or 500 gallons.
- Larger orders. Larger orders get a lower per-gallon price. On October 26, 2026, our posted price was about $5.39 to $6.15 a gallon depending on order size, with the lowest price on the biggest order. Prices move with the wholesale fuel market and can change daily, so check today’s heating oil prices before you decide.
- Filling up before cold weather. Many homeowners like to start winter with a well-filled tank. See why in our post on topping off before the first freeze.
Bigger sizes like 300 and 500 gallons exist for larger tanks or homes with more than one tank. If you have a single 275-gallon tank, you will rarely need them unless the tank is nearly empty and you also have a second tank to fill. If you are not sure, call 631-994-1277 and a local person can talk it through with you.
What if I order too much?
Ordering more oil than the tank can hold is a problem you want to avoid. An overfilled tank can spill from the vent or fill pipe, which is messy and potentially costly. Whoever fills the tank will watch it, but you are the one who knows what is already in it. Give an accurate gauge reading when you call, and when you order online, stay well under the empty space you estimated.
What if I order too little?
Running short is the more common mistake. A 50-gallon order costs a bit more per gallon and may not carry you far. If you think your tank is low and the weather is turning, it usually makes sense to order enough that you will not need to place another order next week. For what happens if the tank hits empty, read what happens if you run out of heating oil.
A simple way to decide
- Read the gauge and subtract it from the tank’s practical capacity.
- Look at how many gallons your last few fills took.
- Order enough to refill most of the way, leaving the headroom the tank needs.
- Write down the date and amount, so next time is easier.
If you would rather not think about it every few weeks, Scheduled Deliveries let you pick a set amount on a set schedule, such as 150 gallons every month, and orders place themselves. You pick the schedule, so adjust it if the winter runs colder or milder than you expected. You can pause, change or cancel from your account at any time.
Ready to order?
Choose your gallons and order online, or call OK Petroleum at 631-994-1277. Orders anywhere on Long Island get free delivery.


