Delivery & Ordering

When Should I Order Heating Oil?

When Should I Order Heating Oil?

Order heating oil before your tank gets low, not after. Most homeowners reorder when the gauge reads around one quarter full, and many top off in the fall before the weather turns cold. Waiting until the tank is nearly empty leaves you no cushion if a cold snap or a busy week delays your delivery.

What is the best time of year to order?

There is no magic date. Heating oil prices follow the wholesale market and can change every day, and nobody can reliably predict the low point. What you can control is when your tank is full. These are the times that make sense for most Long Island homes.

  • Early fall. A full tank going into the heating season means you are ready for the first real cold, and you are not ordering in a rush.
  • Before a forecast cold stretch. If a hard freeze or a storm is coming, order a few days ahead.
  • Mid-winter, before you hit a quarter tank. Winter is the busiest time for every oil company. Early reordering keeps you ahead of the line.
  • Late spring or summer. Some people fill in the off-season when things are calmer. Prices can go up or down, so treat it as a convenience, not a guaranteed saving. We wrote about the idea in why summer can be a smart buy window.

When is my tank low enough to reorder?

A simple rule: reorder at about one quarter of a tank. On a typical 275-gallon tank that is roughly 70 gallons, which can go quickly in January. Check the gauge on a regular schedule, such as the first of every month in fall and every week or two when it is very cold.

Gauges are not perfectly exact, so give yourself some margin. Our guide to the signs it is time to refill lists the clues to watch for.

How far ahead should I order?

Most OK Petroleum orders are delivered same-day or next-day, depending on your area and what time the order comes in, and deliveries usually arrive within 24 hours of the order being processed. That timing is not guaranteed. Cold snaps, high demand, bad weather and road conditions can all slow things down. If that happens, our team contacts you.

So the safest habit is to order while you still have a few days of oil left. If you need oil sooner, call 631-994-1277 and ask about same-day availability. You can read more about it on our same-day heating oil delivery page.

What days and times work best?

You can order online at any hour, which is handy if you notice the gauge on a late night or a weekend. Our office is open Monday to Friday 8AM to 5PM and Saturday 8AM to 12PM, so a phone call is easiest during those hours. If you have set up scheduled deliveries, orders are not placed for Sundays, and Saturday is a delivery day.

You do not have to be home. The driver needs safe, clear access to your fill pipe, so keep the path free of snow and ice.

Should I wait for the price to drop?

It is tempting, but timing the market is hard, and a low tank in the middle of winter is a bad place to be gambling. If your tank is above half and the weather is mild, you have room to watch prices for a few days. If it is near a quarter, order now. The price you wish you had is not worth a cold house.

Larger orders also carry a lower per-gallon price, so ordering earlier, when you can take a bigger delivery, often costs less per gallon than waiting until you only need a small top-off.

What if I wait too long?

Running out of oil in winter is the situation to avoid. Your heat stops, and the burner may need to be restarted once oil is back in the tank. If you are already low, call right away. Our post on what to do when you run low covers the next steps.

Can I take the guesswork out of timing?

Yes. If you know roughly how much your home uses, you can put deliveries on a calendar instead of watching the gauge. With Scheduled Deliveries, you pick the schedule, such as every month or every 2 months, and the gallons per delivery. The orders then place themselves. You can pause, adjust or cancel at any time.

Because you set the schedule, it will not know that a freezing January is using more oil than you planned. Keep an eye on the gauge, and change the schedule when you need to.

Price check before you order

Prices change daily, so look before you buy. On October 26, 2026, the posted range was roughly $5.39 to $6.15 a gallon, depending on order size. See today’s price on our heating oil prices page.

Order when you are ready

Whenever your tank hits that quarter mark, order heating oil online in a few minutes, or call 631-994-1277. We are a family business, and Long Island has been our home turf since 1976.