Heating oil and natural gas can both heat a Long Island home well, and neither one is cheaper in every house or every year. Oil is stored in your own tank and delivered by truck, while natural gas arrives through a utility pipe. Which costs less depends on current prices, your equipment and whether gas is even available on your street.
Side by side
| Factor | Heating oil | Natural gas |
|---|---|---|
| How it arrives | Delivered by truck to a tank on your property | Piped in from a utility main |
| Supplier choice | You can choose or change your delivery company | Usually one local utility provides the gas |
| Availability | Anywhere a truck can reach | Only where a gas line runs to or near the home |
| Storage | You hold a supply in your tank | No tank, no storage |
| Billing | Pay per delivery, by the gallon | Monthly utility bill |
| Price | Moves with the wholesale fuel market | Moves with the gas market and utility rates |
Which one makes more heat?
Heating oil is an energy-dense fuel. A gallon holds roughly 138,500 BTU. Natural gas is sold in therms or cubic feet, and one therm equals 100,000 BTU. Because the units differ, you cannot compare the two by looking at the price tag alone. A fair comparison converts both to the same unit, such as cost per million BTU, and then accounts for how efficient each home’s furnace or boiler is.
The U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA) publishes general information on both fuels if you want to compare current averages. Modern oil and gas equipment can both be efficient, and an older unit of either type wastes more fuel than a new one.
Which is cheaper?
It depends, and anyone who gives you a flat answer is guessing. Oil prices follow the wholesale fuel market and can change daily. Gas prices follow their own market and the utility’s rates. The two have moved in different directions at different times. See our deeper write-ups on whether gas or oil heat is cheaper and oil heat vs. gas heat for Long Island homes.
For oil, you can check what we are charging at any time on our heating oil prices page. For a snapshot, OK Petroleum’s posted range on October 26, 2026 was roughly $5.39 to $6.15 per gallon, depending on the order. For gas, look at your utility bill and its current rates, then compare using the same unit.
What does it cost to switch?
Switching from oil to gas is a project, not just a new fuel. In general terms, you may pay for a gas line connection if there is no service to your house, a new gas furnace or boiler, or a conversion burner on the existing unit, plus work on the venting, and sometimes removal or abandonment of the old oil tank. Costs vary widely with the house and the street, so get written quotes from licensed contractors and ask the utility what a hookup would involve.
Whether the switch pays off depends on how much you save per year compared with how much the project costs. That math is only as good as the fuel prices you assume, and prices change. Our post on converting to natural gas on Long Island lists the questions to ask before you commit. Do not let anyone rush you into a switch.
Which is safer?
Both are used safely in millions of homes when equipment is installed correctly and serviced regularly. The risks are different.
- Natural gas is piped into the house, and a leak can be dangerous. Utilities add a rotten-egg odor so leaks are noticeable. If you ever smell gas, leave the home and call the utility or 911 from outside.
- Heating oil is a liquid stored in a tank. The main concern is a leak or spill from an aging tank or fittings, which is why regular inspection matters.
- Both are combustion fuels, so every home should have working carbon monoxide detectors and an annual tune-up.
What about independence from the utility?
This is where oil owners often feel most strongly. With oil, you own the tank and the fuel inside it, and you decide who delivers. If a delivery company is not serving you well, you can call another one. With gas, your fuel comes through the pipe and your supplier is typically set by where you live. That also means that a gas customer never has to worry about the tank running dry, which is a real advantage for some households.
The practical answer
If your home already runs on oil, the best next step is usually to keep the equipment tuned and shop for a good, local delivery company. If gas is available and your oil equipment is near the end of its life, get quotes and run the numbers with current prices. Our article heating oil vs. propane vs. natural gas adds propane to the mix.
If you stay with oil, OK Petroleum would be glad to deliver. Order online in a few minutes, or call 631-994-1277. There is no delivery fee on Long Island orders, and you see the price before you check out.



